Spain Halts Renewable Subsidies to Curb $31 Billion of Debts
Spain halted subsidies for renewable energy projects to help curb
its budget deficit and rein in power-system borrowings backed by the
state that reached 24 billion euros ($31 billion) at the end of 2011.
"What is today an energy problem could become a financial problem,"
Industry Minister Jose Manuel Soria said in Madrid.
passed a decree today stopping subsidies for new wind, solar,
co-generation or waste incineration plants.
The system's debts were racked up as revenue from state- controlled
prices failed to cover the cost of delivering power.
Costs have swollen in the past five years because of an increase in
regulated payments for the power grid, support for Spanish coal
mines and subsidies for renewable energy plants.
"It's clear they have to make major cuts,"
said Francisco Salvador, a strategist at FGA/MG Valores in Madrid.
"The government has already ruled out a significant increase in
prices, so the cuts will fall in many places and the spotlight is
on renewables, but not just on renewables."
Renewables companies fell on the Spanish action.
Vestas Wind Systems A/S (VWS), the biggest wind-turbine maker,
slid as much as 2.9 percent in Copenhagen. Abengoa SA, a Spanish
engineering firm specializing in solar mirrors, dropped as much
as 2.2 percent in Madrid and Iberdrola SA (IBE), the biggest
renewable energy producer based in Bilbao, declined as much as 1.5 percent.
Spain's decision is a "first step" to rein in debts, and officials are
working on a broader package of measures, Soria said.
The nation isn't planning a levy on hydropower or nuclear plants, nor
will it take on power-system liabilities, he said.
The Spanish action follows Germany's announcement last week that it
would phase out support for solar panels by 2017 and the U.K.'s legal
battle to reduce its subsidies for the industry.
Spain was an early mover in developing renewables plants, and
support for wind energy helped Iberdrola become the world's biggest
producer of clean power, with plants in the U.S. and Brazil.
The industry sustains about 110,000 Spanish jobs, according to the
Renewable Energy Producers Association.
The government is wrestling with competing priorities as it struggles
to convince investors it can meet a target to cut the budget deficit
to 4.4 percent of gross domestic product this year, from 8 percent
last year, while trying to create jobs in a country where 23 percent
of workers are unemployed.
"This is shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted,"
said Peter Sweatman, chief executive officer of consultant Climate
"The risk is that Spanish firms that are recognized global
leaders in renewable energy feel their position undermined by
lack of domestic support."
Generating capacity is about twice Spain's peak demand following a
boom in investment in solar panel installations and combined-cycle
gas-fired plants, while the country is ahead of its targets for
clean power production, Soria said.
The suspension won't affect operating plants or projects
that have already been approved for subsidies by the government, he said.
"It's a real positive for the developers, the owners of assets,
because it removes the risk of retroactive cuts," said Sean
McLoughlin, a renewable energy analyst at HSBC Plc.
"The government could certainly have done that again when you
think of how much it's costing them but have decided not to.
This suggests that the government is listening to the industry."